District 9 - A Review [Caution, contains spoilers]

By Banzai · Sep 18, 2009 · ·
Categories:
  1. I realise this is a string of good reviews, but I'm not kidding when I say this is my tip for film of the year. It was nothing short of brilliant, from start to finish.

    To begin , the concept was fantastic. Aliens not as superior beings, but as almost refugees. To the best of my knowledge, there hasn't been a present-day use of such an idea before. And the choice of location (Johannesburg) was perfect. As a sociological metaphor it may be a little blunt, but the similarities between alien segregation and the apartheid which was so brutal in South Africa makes it all the more potent.

    The intro and outro of the film as extracts from a documentary is not a new concept, but it has been used before to great effect, and is done so again here. It introduces the situation without feeling utterly contrived, and the hints it gives as to the ending of the film are tantalising, but do not destroy suspense.

    It also seems completely realistic. Humanity is not a tolerant race, and the all-accepting humanity depicted in Star Trek, etc, is centuries away if not complete fiction. If there was an arrival of aliens on this planet, then they would have to do us huge favours in regards to technological advances for us to even consider accepting them. An unpalatable conclusion, yes, but I fear it's true, and this film capitalises on that. It is at times very uncomfortable, primarily because it rings so true. The MNU's treatment of the "Prawns" is so similar to the treatment suffered at various points in history by black people/Jews/native Americans/black South Africans and countless other peoples deemed "different". It is also horrific, and undeniably wrong.

    As a main character Wikus is perfect for the story. He is, at the beginning, just as guilty of the racism as anyone else, and possibly worse because he thinks he isn't. He is also a weak, and yet fundametally good person. He is realistic as a person intimidated by those overbearing individuals (his father-in-law/boss, and the military commander of the MNU forces) around him. When he is contaminated with the alien "fluid", and he begins to change, the reaction of the MNU is consistent with the most paranoid conspiracy story- complete disregard for him as well as the prawns, int he pursuit of advanced technology and the profits it would bring.

    Conversely, the "barbarity" of the prawns is portrayed as being because of a mixture of cultural-difference, their treatment by the humans, and their being the "worker class" of their people. The film states that before they were brought to district 9, they had been trapped aboard their ship for months, making clear that they had known nothing but incarceration for a long time.

    The character of "Christopher Johnson" (a good play, in giving the alien a human name, to humanise him, and conversely dehumanise the MNU, to an even greater degree) was everything a hero should be. His only concern, to begin with, is to get himself and his son home. But by the end, he has seen the experiments that humanity has been doing on his people, and wants nothing more than to save them. The selflessness of an alien seems profoundly more human to the audience than the self-centred lack of empathy by its human characters.

    But aside from the sociological metaphors, it is a bloody good film. The prawns are brilliantly animated, and the sight of the huge spaceship in all of the wide-angle shots in Johannesburg is a triumph of CGI as a tool of the filmmaker rather than simply the star of the film, as well as a constant reminder of the aliens' presence. In particular the battle in District 9 between Wikus and Christopher, the MNU and the Nigerian criminals, is spectacularly choreographed, with my particular favourite moment being when Wikus- in an alien battle suit- catches an RPG to allow Christopher the time to reach the mothership.

    And that's the thing about this film. It checks all boxes. It has the deep and intellectual aspect of the sociological anagolies, it has the action of the chases and gunfights, and it even has the tragically pathetic romance between Wikus and his wife. And it's an incredibly well made film. The whole thing fits perfectly together.

    The only jarring moments I encountered were that Wikus seems to revert to a scouse accent when he swears, and that the MNU colonel looks disconcertingly like Bruce Willis.

    But overall, the setting in South Africa was the thing I liked most. It wasn't in America, which is very refreshing. I counted one, maybe two, American accents in the whole thing, amid an abundance of South African accents. It was fresh, it was different, it tried something new. And it pulled it off.

    If you haven't seen this, go and see it. Now. Do it!
    Categories:

Comments

  1. Gannon
    Agreed, great film, but a couple more niggles from my side, one of which is not Wikus's sketchy accent, which, I'm led to believe, is entirely real.

    One - how are the aliens and the humans mutually comprehensible? No explanation given. No translator microbes here!

    Two - would need to see it again to be sure, but why do the aliens not fight back? They have superior firepower (perhaps not brainpower). The mothership coming to life does seem to empower the weaponry, but it works beforehand. See the test lab.

    And finally, I was a little disappointed it descended into a hollywood-type action film when it started out far from one. At the climax, it is a buddy movie, with outlandish 'baddy' deaths and a near unkillable main baddy in the Bruce Willis-alike merc.

    Nice that it didn't finish with total annihilation of either side and open to ambiguity as to what happens next. However, please to god no sequel. It would be, I imagine, super awful.
  2. jonathan hernandez13
    Interesting review, I had no idea what to expect other than to expect to be pleasantly surprised, and I was-I guess.

    It reminded me of the television and film versions of the "Alien Nation" franchise, however, unlike AN, D9 didnt seem to make any attempt to explore the cultures of humans and aliens and how they interacted. They briefly skimmed the surface, but I still know next to nothing about the prawns, other than that really like cat food?:confused:

    They can do better than that, at least I know that I can.

    The end of the film became a war film, a very gory, bloody, vicious war film. I felt that the filmakers had taken advantage of me, they spent the entire film demonizing humans so that when a bunch of humans were getting wasted I would want to cheer. I do not like being compelled to glamorize overt violence. Lets not make a virtue out of killing.

    The end gives us no compromise or resolution, I am left with no closure. The MC that I spent hours with and began to identify with turned into a bug and we have no idea what will happen to him. None. The vast conspiracy that was responsible for all of this anarchy is never directly dealt with, only their gun toting brute squad who are dismembered with technology thats never irrationally explained.

    Not a bad film, not a great one, a surprise of a film, mostly from the last thirty or so minutes of butt-clenching action, most of which can be found in any big budget action blockbuster, and with less unnecessary bug genocide.:(
  3. Xeno
    "One - how are the aliens and the humans mutually comprehensible? No explanation given. No translator microbes here!"

    They've been there for twenty years, I'm sure many people in Johannasburg (especially those in Wikus' line of work) would have the grasp of the alien's language by now (and vice versa) but there are scenes where Wikus does ask Christopher to repeat himself.

    "Two - would need to see it again to be sure, but why do the aliens not fight back? They have superior firepower (perhaps not brainpower). The mothership coming to life does seem to empower the weaponry, but it works beforehand. See the test lab."

    It was established that the vast majority of aliens in District 9 were of the 'worker' class and were therefore more primeval in terms of intelligence and aptitude, so they're just really staying where they're put. When they decide to kill something, they use their hands.

    I enjoyed the climax of the film, it had the sort of frantic fight-for-survival that you would expect from someone who's life has just gone down the s**tter and someone trying to save his own species. I don't see why it having the thrills of a 'big budget action blockbuster' is a problem, because it isn't. Even when the massive robot thing is blowing sh*t up you get the sense that Wikus is doing it out of desperation, rather than the 'big budget action blockbuster' approach of I-am-holier-than-thou. Besides, the main point is that this isn't a big budget action blockbuster, it's much more detailed and intruiging.

    I loved it.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice