Sense of Location Anyone?

By Oscar Leigh · Apr 19, 2016 · ·
  1. So, this one is going to be one of the more angry rant pieces. You ready for the ride? :twisted: (Clicks imaginary pen menacingly) :write:
    Have you ever noticed how sometimes in fiction, especially in television shows, people seem to sometimes talk very private things in not so private places while people are around? Like one guy student will be in the middle of a hall full of other students and yet confess how he's dating a closeted guy also from the school. Or two agents dicuss that they work for some secret organisation devoted to saving the world from secret aliens while walking down a main street. Or two culprits discuss their plans for dealing with a police investigation while in a ballroom. It just seems like it's easy enough to either move, or wait, rather than have a risk someone might, you know, OVERHEAR. :supermad::supermad:
    Now, I'm a pretty bloody honest person, but I do have some things I don't just tell. And some of those things I'm very careful with. I wouldn't just go blurting them out where someone might here. Not unless I slip up. Which is the issue, nobody regrets it, and nobody stops the other and says "hey, could we do this someplace else?" Not in the scenes I'm talking about. Other scenes do have the grace to do one of those and spare my keyboard from angry high-speed typing.
    Which brings me to the question: why do writers write these scenes? It seems like they are doing it for no reason. Why didn't they just write the scene with the character have a better sense of location? It's not like it's harder. Just design the scene differently. You don't have to change anything as long as you don't set up the stupid version. ANYTHING but the stupid version! :supermad:
    It just screws with my suspension of disbelief, however much I'm suspending it, when I see this occur. I end up spending half the time reading/watching the scene thinking, why are you doing this HERE? :confused:
    "Oh, I have this secret thing I want to talk about, let's do it where FIFTEEN OTHER PEOPLE COULD HEAR!!!!" :supermad::supermad::supermad::supermad:
    Does anyone know why this happens? Because it really pisses me off.
    Maybe it's because they're hoping other conversation will distract people/drown out the sound? But that seems too risky to me, why bother taking that risk? Especially when it's with characters dealing with really serious secrets that affect hundreds/thousands/millions of people. Can't they just pick A BETTER SPOT?!! :supermad:
    I'm very picky about this stuff, I admit. I often think that they should be going for maximum possible realism. If it's a plot point, like magic, fine, but everything else why not just be realistic? I mean, my thoughts on writing are obviously superior, right? I'll never understand this weird race called "other people". Urgh.
    But seriously, this one I struggle to forgive. Why??
    Anyone got any thoughts on this they'd like to share?
    Thank you for your time. Hope you have a good day. :blowkiss::blowkiss:

Comments

  1. Kate Sen
    Good point.

    Could it be that script writers do not have enough experience telling secrets, so they do not realize the scene is inappropriate? Or maybe the less important actors belong to a union, and have a right to at least x number of minutes per movie, and if they did not get their screen time during the secret scenes the movie would have to be extended even further? Maybe the main actors are too extroverted, and do not do as well if on stage with just one other person? Maybe they found that making such scenes too realistic caused viewers to suspend their disbelief too much, and they want to keep viewers grounded in the reality that this is just an unrealistic movie? Maybe it costs too much to hire a quality control person to validate the movies for common sense?

    That's all the possible reasons I could come up with at this time.
  2. Oscar Leigh
    I was thinking it's probably something to do with giving you something to look at while they talk. Because OBVIOUSLY the audience are impatient fucks who can't stand slow character moments even when they're interesting and important. I suspect that's at least part of it.
      KokoN and Kate Sen like this.
  3. KokoN
    Yeah, I find this annoying too. I watch a lot of mystery/crime shows and the detectives are always discussing top secret crime details where multiple other people could hear them, lol. I think you're right though that it's just because they think the audience will get bored, but it still is pretty dumb.
      Oscar Leigh likes this.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice