And I don't mean once they made you cry. I mean, every single time you read it, or think about a passage in the book, it brings tears to your eyes against your will. For me, the books that do this the most are the Dark-Hunter novels by Sherrilyn Kenyon. In Night Play, Bride is this rubenesque woman who gets dumped by her dirtbag of a boyfriend via a letter he charges to her FedEx account. This is in the first few pages alone and I cry for her every single time.