Would it be possible to work on a post that explains what IS and what is NOT a helpful review? I feel like a lot of people are just joining and responding to two posts with "I liked this, you could change a few things but otherwise it's good". Then when these people post their own story, all I see is that they have more than 2 posts so I assume they've made their contribution. After spending thirty minutes reviewing them, I take a look at their posts and see that they've just left two stories a useless two-line comment. My reviews aren't anything amazing, but at least I try to put some thought into what I'm saying to help them make specific changes. Cogito does a great job of catching these people and locking their threads, but if there was a sticky/announcement we could just put at the top of each review forum (my specific problem is in the Novel forum right now, not sure if others are experiencing the same issues in other forums) with guidelines on how to leave a HELPFUL review. Anyone have any thoughts on this?