What gets defined as it? What is it? More importantly, what are the thematic things, the tropes that appear more often, and so on? I've read a little that would probably be classed as it, but then I got told that my story was urban fantasy, when I felt it was absolutely nothing alike to any I'd ever read/heard people talk about/watched movies about, etc. Or do I just have a narrow stereotypical view? Is it literally just modern age + magic = urban fantasy, or should the definition be narrower? Edit: is this a debate everyone who *cares* about the genre has already hashed out years ago and I'm just coming slow to?