Brief backstory: I have a small but diverse group of betas who read my stories, they're always very helpful, and I am grateful to have them. Most of them have very different tastes from one another which usually makes for a good mix of feedback. Yesterday, for the first time, this caused a conundrum. Beta 1 loved my most recent story and said x and y worked really well and made the story. Beta 2 hated my most recent story and said x and y did not work at all and ruined the whole thing. After some discussion, Beta 2 and I came to the conclusion that Beta 2 is probably just the wrong audience for my most recent story as it isn't her usual genre and she hates x on principle. No big deal. It happens. I'll write again and she'll read again. That said, it got me thinking. Have any of you ever had two trusted betas give you the exact opposite feedback? What did you make of it?