1. Published on Amazon? If you have a book, e-book, or audiobook available on Amazon.com, we'll promote it on WritingForums.org for free. Simply add your book to our Member Publications section. Add your book here or read the full announcement.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Dismiss Notice

How I Review

Published by JoeMusings in the blog JoeMusings's blog. Views: 109

My Grading Scale

A+ = Get this published. Now!
A = This is really good. I want to read it again.
A- = This is almost really good, with a few minor fumbles.
B+ = This is good with some really enjoyable qualities.
B = I can honestly say I enjoyed this.
B- = This is slightly ahead of the curb.
C+ = This is average, with a few qualities I liked.
C = This is average.
C- = This is okay. A little below average.
D+ = If you work really hard, this can become good.
D = If you work really hard, this can become decent.
D- = I wouldn't bother revising this.
F = Don't even bother revising this.

How I Review

One of the minor gripes I have with this community is the narrow scope it applies when reviewing posts. I see reviewers annotate posts with detailed precision, and focus too narrowly on the mechanics of each sentence.

I believe a reviewer should evaluate a piece more as a whole. Especially if the poster clearly has a grasp on grammar, there is no need to fixate too heavily on each sentence. More often than not, the poster can revise the mechanics of a piece on his or her own. What the poster may not understand is how his or her piece in its entirety affects an unbiased reader. With this in mind, I strongly encourage reviewers on this site to widen the scopes of their reviews.
  • Cogito
  • Mercurial
  • Forkfoot
You need to be logged in to comment