Oversensitivity vs. Creative Freedom - A Brief Reminder for 2016

By Link the Writer · Jan 24, 2016 · ·
  1. (Partially inspired by Wrey's blog about clichés, tropes, and how everything's been done before.)
    ----------------------------------------------
    Hello, hello! I hope the first month of the new year had been kind to you writers, new and veterans alike. Though I'm a month late, I felt I wanted to remind the new writers this year of something in case they get a niggling little feeling in their guts about whether or not a character, setting, or a concept in their story would offend someone.

    A brief reminder:


    You are going to offend someone. That's life.



    You cannot please everyone.


    No matter what you write, you're gonna piss someone off. Here are some of the classic examples and the broad reactions to that.

    Write a white, heterosexual male protagonist
    "OMGWTFBBQ!!? So bland! So dull! So unoriginal! Where's my representation!"

    Write a non-white, homo/hetero female protagonist?
    "OMGWTFBBQ, PC LIBERAL SJW SCUM!!!"

    Write a strong, badass female protagonist?
    "ERMIGERD, A MAN WITH BOOBS!"/"MARY-SUE!"

    Write a female who would rather stay home and knit?
    "OMGOMGOMGWTFBBQ, YOU SEXIST PIG!!"

    Write a disabled character?
    "OMG! YOU JUST PUT HIM/HER THERE TO CHECK A BOX IN YOUR PC-LIST!"

    Write a non-disabled character?
    "WHERE'S OUR REPRESENTATION!? THANK YOU FOR SAYING WE DON'T EXIST!!!!"

    Just write what you want to write. Make the characters you want to create. I don't care who are what they are. The point is for you to write the story regardless. If the story involves a white, heterosexual male, fine. If it involves an Asian woman with deformities who falls in love with a sexy Russian woman and they have hot, hot sex in a four-starred hotel in Moscow, that's fine too. If it serves your story, DO IT!! Not including a character from this or that group doesn't make you a bad person. I could have Amos (my Colonial detective) drop dead of cancer (back then, it was known as 'the wasting disease'), sure, but I won't because that won't help the story I want to tell, that's not what the story is about. Same if I gave Mishu (my fantasy protagonist) a heart condition that'd kill her if she didn't take her meds. It's not her character, it's not what the story is about, so she doesn't have a heart condition. This doesn't mean I secretly hate people with cancer or have heart conditions. It's simply not the story I'm writing.

    No matter what you do, no matter what you write, you're gonna piss off some group or other. You are, of course, free to write about characters who are women, not white, LBGT+, or have a disease or a condition but do it because you feel it's right, because you wanted to write it, not because you were peer-pressured by society to write something you may not want to write about.

    In closing: someone's going to be offended, and that's their right. You get to write whatever the hell you want regardless. Don't restrain yourself, don't put chains on your creativity. Don't let the fear of offending someone kill your desire to write.

    Now write on! Have a happy 2016!

    :write::read:

Comments

  1. Lifeline
    HAH!

    Thank you Link, that was just what I needed to hear right this moment. Am struggling through a real difficult scene which I don't want to write. Because it makes me be afraid of the reactions of people out there, yes that's right! So this little piece of advice was really needed right this second. I would write anyway because it just fits in with the story, but sometimes that doesn't matter at all to the little kid screaming in the back of my head. This kid who wants to be loved, who wants everyone to be in love with her novel.

    That will not happen, though, of that I am real confident. Nevertheless the story needs to be told that way. So thanks for extending a helping hand here :)
      Link the Writer likes this.
  2. AlcoholicWolf
    It also pays to remember that nobody has the right not to be offended - being offended is meaningless. Someone could be offended by the colour combination I wore to the shops today. I'm not the type to go around hurting people's feelings, but you have to admit human beings will try and find fault with anything they can!
      Link the Writer likes this.
  3. Adenosine Triphosphate
    Our culture is a warzone, a never-ending struggle between groups and ideologies of all banners. Because every side perceives the other as self-righteous, there is little hope for understanding, and because the battle rages in so many different directions, our everyday language is more corrupted by aggression and stereotypes than most people would hope or care to understand.

    For the few that catch a glimpse—liberals, for the most part—the first impulse is to rail against it, but this can quickly lead to paralysis, and the end result may simply fan the flames in yet another direction. I became aware of this drawback around a year ago, but I spent much of the time afterward policing my own mind to avoid being pretentious or politically correct, which was a betrayal of everything I believe.

    In the end, the only solution is that there isn't one. It is impossible to avoid offending people, and it is almost impossible to avoid being offensive. There are simply so many different stereotypes that one could never hope to avoid them all. From that understanding, I learn that beating myself up over many of the lighter transgressions is pointless, because I would simply replace them with other faults, and I would cripple my freedom in the process.
      Link the Writer likes this.
  4. Link the Writer
    Exactly, @Adenosine Triphosphate . Too many times I've observed that people swing from one side of the fence to the other. It's either “Meh, fuck their feelings, they're nothing!” or “We must treat them like delicate eggshells!”

    Even with me, a half-blind and mostly deaf man, I find myself stumbling into clichés/stereotypes I thought I knew how to avoid. Right now with my fantasy-mystery novel, I'm doing the best I can to not only show the difficulties Mishu would have to put up with because of her disabilities, but to show that her disabilities aren't all that she is. A part of me fears that this would be offensive anyhow because of the ‘Inspirationally Disabled’ stereotype. Y'know, “Wow, you're so incredible because you're disabled! Your disability is all that you are, and we admire you overcoming it!!”

    I could sit down and worry about it all day, worry about whether or not I'm depicting her just right without pissing off the disabled community but I won't. I can't because that won't help me write the story I want to write. All I can do is write Mishu to the best of my ability and hope she comes out OK.

    There's another mystery I'm working on, set in our world, modern times. The MC is your generic college football kid, white, Christian male, etc. The only difference is that he's hearing-impaired and is an orphan living with his (kind, yes, thank you) aunt and uncle. His story demands to be written. He is the main character, yet his best friend is a fellow (black) college student named Adrian. My PC side picks at me, asking why he isn't the MC, or hell, the girl in the ice cream shop who has albinism, why she isn't the MC. Why Kevin McGringo Americano College Boy? Or-or why did I have it set in the US? Why not Canada? Germany? Pakistan?

    Because this is Kevin's story, and he just so happens to live in the US. If it were Adrian's, then he would've been the MC. If the story were set in Germany, it would've been set in Germany. I think we writers should have this scribed into our mindset: “We have the freedom to write whatever we damned well please. Our characters will be whatever we want them to be -- and it doesn't make us villains if we make them one way or another. Our settings, our plots, the things we wish to talk about will be based on what we as authors decide, not what society as a whole thinks we should do. They can get upset all they want, but at the end of the day, we will not kill the story we want to write because we're afraid this will upset someone, somewhere.”

    Whatever story you want to write, write it. I don't care if it's about some white college kid who solves murder mysteries in rural America (wait, that's my story so you can't have it! :p) or a spicy lesbian romance between a Russian woman and a deformed Mongolian woman. Write it. Who cares who gets offended. The only criticism you'd want to listen to anyway are the ones that'll improve your writing.

    So get to writing, folks!!!
  5. Lifeline
    If it would only be so easy Link!

    I am not knocking what you say, in fact I agree completely. Yet society made laws, some of them real stupid but they are out there. I live in the UK and I have to be careful what I include in my novel if I want to ever give it out. I write certain stuff for myself at the moment, but the version of my novel which gets given out will not include what I am currently writing for myself. Because of laws. Yep.

    But.. being the stubborn Alice in Dark Wonderland that I am, I am writing it anyway!! I just don't have to let people see. One-in-your-eye-you-stupid-fucking-easily-offended-society!!
      Link the Writer likes this.
  6. 123456789
    Link, I don't know about you, but the planet I live on is not Shrangri-la. We live in a world where people compete with one another for everything from income to food to mating, where huge economic, political, and international injustices go by uncontested, and where a Facebook status is more important than the homeless man down on the street beneath you. The greatest thing about fiction is that it is free from all constraints, it is the one place where an author can be whatever it wants, and where any idea can be explored. If the ideal wife is a lady in the living-room and a whore in the bedroom, than the ideal world is one where compassion, respect, and reason are applied at all times other than in entertainment.Unfortunately, it seems some people would refer the reverse -equality in fiction and inequality in reality- because it is much easier to achieve. It's up to you to lead by example in your day to day interactions with others, and then forget about all that (if you choose) when writing fiction.
  7. Imaginarily
    Ah, my pupil is all grown up. :-D
      Link the Writer likes this.
  8. lastresort
    So it's OK to use an old homophobic, racist, sexist male Aussie proud of his anglo-saxon convict roots as an MC?
      Link the Writer likes this.
  9. Imaginarily
    It's okay to write whatever you want, @lastresort. It's freedom of expression, go nuts.
  10. lastresort
    Being a real prude by nature, I'll end up offending myself. But I get your point. :)
      Link the Writer and Imaginarily like this.
  11. Link the Writer
    Absolutely, @lastresort . You can write whatever the hell you want. If that's the character you want to write, go for it. To hell what others say about what you can or can't write.
      Imaginarily likes this.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice