PRE-BANNING terrifying new trend?

By peachalulu · Feb 4, 2019 · ·
  1. Just read another story of a woman named Amelie Zhao having her book deal yanked after some people on Goodreads decided her book didn't meet up to certain standards? I don't know how else you'd call it. A fantasy novel - set in a fantasy world didn't mirror certain aspects of … reality. Not shocked … just uneasy. What did she do wrong? Apparently wrote about slavery without mentioning POC. My feeling on this is whoopdee-shit. If I read a book and no characters looked like me - who cares, if they don't represent certain religions, atheism, certain viewpoints, certain real world issues - again, who gives a shit. I'm there to read their take on their world and if it doesn't include anything of, or not of my world - who cares. Apparently though a noisy group of people care and seriously want to destroy a person's career before it even has a chance to flower. Some of the kooks accused her of being anti-black, a plagiarist (and if she's guilty of that she should be called out) and a flat out racist.
    I think the publishers have pulled publishing the trilogy temporarily which makes me think the books are probably being groomed and reworked to pacify the mob-squad before being sold.
    Scary.
    No concrete proof of racism, no proof of malicious intent, no proof of bias. But somehow still found guilty.
    And the writer apologized. Reminds me a little of Canada when someone bumps into you - you apologize before the person who bumped you. What I used to think as funny isn't so funny anymore.
    I have no idea what kind of message this sends to writers. I'm caught between terror that we're pre-banning people and possibly encouraging people to write with a certain mindset versus the exhilaration that it's forcing me to take a good look at what I believe in.

Comments

  1. jim onion
    You've got to be one hard son-of-a-bitch and fight these fucking fools to the end. It's the only way.

    NEVER apologize. That was her first mistake.

    Authors who are naïve to the current political landscape and these bullying tactics will be caught completely off guard and immediately bow down and kiss the earth their aggressors walk on. The shock will be so sudden and significant that they'll think they themselves are in the wrong, and not the political activists.

    The same thing is happening in the anime industry with shows like Goblin Slayer and Rise of the Shield Hero, the last of which radical feminists were in an uproar over because the main character is the victim of a false rape accusation, something that does not compute in the delusional world they inhabit.

    This is happening in every corner of the entertainment industry. And you're right. It's scary. But most people on here have laughed at me, been actively in support of it, or are apathetic. Good on you for caring.
  2. ThunderAngel
    It's sad that something as potentially wonderful as social justice has been turned into something so vindictive and spiteful that people will aggressively seek the ruin of others for the most innocent of reasons. Never apologize to people who overreact; they won't forgive you anyway, so they don't deserve the effort.
      Malisky and peachalulu like this.
  3. peachalulu
    Thanks. I come from a family of artists and this is so against everything I was taught about art expression that it's frightening to find people/writers - I mean come on - words are our palette - so indifferent about it. I'm not sure if it's because they figure they'll never write anything that would be considered offensive or they'd correct it if anyone called them on it.
    I know it would be extremely hard to turn down a book deal but … caving to bully tactics would be even harder to live with. For me anyway.
    I think they don't forgive because I think they know deep down there was nothing to apologize for, therefore they know the apology cannot be sincere. It's like us Canadians apologizing when someone bumps us - our automatic apology isn't sincere cause we did nothing wrong. It's meant to placate.
    You can still stand up for what you believe in and incorporate it into your art. You're going to attract more interest to a cause/belief with love, and truth and honor then you will with a lot of finger pointing.
      Foxxx likes this.
  4. GrahamLewis
    There's always someone who has said what I want to say better than I can do it myself. Like this:

    “It's now very common to hear people say, 'I'm rather offended by that.' As if that gives them certain rights. It's actually nothing more... than a whine. 'I find that offensive.' It has no meaning; it has no purpose; it has no reason to be respected as a phrase. 'I am offended by that.' Well, so fucking what."

    [I saw hate in a graveyard -- Stephen Fry, The Guardian, 5 June 2005]”
    ― Stephen Fry
  5. peachalulu
    It's a whine but it's also major manipulation. It totally shuts down any chance at having a risky conversation. Take the situation with Liam Neeson - the guy basically self confesses to thought crime and is pronounced guilty. I guess the idea of encouraging men to express their feelings rather than suppress them should be more thought out - read the fine print, gentlemen. Lol.
      Foxxx likes this.
  6. GrahamLewis
    I should also add that this is hardly a new phenomenon. I have before me a book entitled Law in Action, An Anthology of the Law in Literature, published in 1947. It includes a copy of the federal court decision, in 1933, ruling that James Joyce's Ulysses should be allowed to be distributed in the United States, dismissing an action banning it brought by the U.S. government as obscene.
      peachalulu and Foxxx like this.
  7. jim onion
    ^That was a wise decision. Good book? (Law in Action, I mean)
  8. GrahamLewis
    Not especially. I "inherited" it when the federal judge I worked for (a different one) died and his family told me to take any books I wanted from his library. It's mostly of interest to legal scholars and the like, though some things are interesting and worth reading. Others are written in ye olde language and more trouble to read than they seem to be worth.
      Foxxx likes this.
  9. Username Required
    Yes, there’s a lot of censorship these days against people who offend our woke overlords. I’m a poet (Joshua C. Frank, published mainly at the Society of Classical Poets website), and few places will even consider my poetry (even if it isn’t controversial) because of the published work of mine that they’ve already seen. But, still, I write, because the truth needs to get out there.
      peachalulu likes this.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice