Putting a value on words

By GrahamLewis · Dec 17, 2017 · ·
  1. This is probably a more personal entry than most. I am really torn about how much value writing has for its own sake. Here's why I wonder. All my life I have been told what a wonderful writer I am, by all sorts of people and, in fact, it seems to have been borne out by most things I have written, from law briefs to correspondence to small little imageries I call "vignettes" to website posts. I wrote for awhile for a small newspaper and got lots of commendable comments. There's some value, boosts to my self-esteem.

    And writing is the one time that I can get outside myself. When I'm really in the writing, I am really in the flow, whether it be first draft, rewrites, or rewriting rewrites. I feel alive and empowered. There's more value.

    But I have never earned money in the capacity as a pure writer. I'm retired from my work now, but in a relationship where I need to justify my writing, and it keeps getting examined in a financial sense. How does one work out that balance? If I never get published? I remember reading somewhere that men become writers because of (1) money, (2) fame, and (3) women. And I know that at least one famous author has said something to the effect that "anyone who writes for other than money is a fool." He had fame too, but was silent about women.

    I suppose in a way it goes back to the old "art for art's sake" argument. Which makes me think the answer is that being creative has value extraneous to the commercial and day-to-day world. Van Gogh created masterpieces that were not really appreciated during his lifetime. And he died of suicide, a pauper. There's no way of knowing the effect his act of painting had on him, but I at least am convinced that work alone is what kept him going as long as he did.

    So that throws me back at the beginning. If I write and am never successfully published, have I made meaningful contributions to anything? Meaningful, I mean, to anyone beyond myself. That briefly touching the hearts or minds of close family and friends has value, even though it doesn't feed the bulldog.

    I only hope the answer is "yes" and that there is a broader universe in which the act of being creative has value in itself. If I answer yes, does that make it true?
    Anntoninette and Rani99 like this.

Comments

  1. Lankle
    For me the answer is yes. Writing is a hobby but one that brings me pleasure and challenge. I hope to contribute to the world of writing some day because stories, for me, are one of the best things about being human.
    It sounds like your question may go beyond your expectations and into the expectations of others. You have already contributed to the world of work and are now retired, does your hobby really have to earn you money? If you were into bowling or birdwatching would anyone expect you to earn money from it?
    Value could be calculated in terms of your own enjoyment, your own experience. It may not be possible or inevitable that others in your life understand. It may also not be necessary that they do.
      Anntoninette and Rani99 like this.
  2. GrahamLewis
    Thanks for the answer, Lankle. Especially the comment about the expectations of others. I agree with you, though it's not always easy to discount the views of others. But I think you are right on.

    And I agree about stories being important as a sharing of experience with others and as being valuable in their own right (write? [with apologies to John Lennon]). Heck, I agree totally.
      Anntoninette likes this.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice