Teenage Angst or "Being New to the Writer's Forum"

By Imo · Jul 12, 2010 · ·
  1. I know I am not alone.

    The fear of failure seems to be universal. Most of us have tasted it in one form or the other. Big events or small, sooner or later there will be a moment where you wish to excel, and that is where the fear begins.

    It is all perfectly fine and manageable while within closed doors but for a writer, or any artist, there comes that moment when sharing with yourself is no longer enough.

    Submitting your work for review takes courage, I imagine. I say 'imagine' as I have not yet tried this personally although the facts that: I am eligible to post, have a nearly finished piece, and can't imagine ever considering it fit for review, does sound some warning bells.

    I can't describe the terror I feel at the mere thought of posting my work for review. Even writing a critique leaves me with clammy hands and a racing pulse.

    From the many posts dealing with this topic, I know I am not the only one going through this phase but it doesn't help. Neither does the reassurance that excellence is not expected.

    I am aware that this is a workshop, a tool to learn and share but the nagging sense of discomfort stays. What if my comments steer the author in the wrong direction? What if I come across as ignorant, blunt or worse, arrogant? Who am I to critique writers of far greater skills than my own?

    I fidget and reread my critiques, dreading to hit that damning enter key. I want to delete my intended post, I want to rephrase it and edit until it has a semblance of sanity. I want to sound like I know what I'm doing when I am really just floundering about.

    Posting my first critique almost took more courage than I possess but after much deliberation I did hit that enter key. I had expected relief - done is done, after all - but I felt more nervous than before and waited anxiously for other posters to shine their light on the piece I had just critiqued. Would they agree with me?

    In the end, what other reviewers thought didn't matter as the author replied. "Thank you, I found your comments very helpful." A free quote, but it gets the message across.

    That message did more good than any of the previous reassurances. It inspired me to critique again, and helped me to realize I had indeed learned something. I had learned to overcome my fears of failing in the public eye.

    I doubt it will ever fully go away and perhaps that is just as well, but that simple 'thank you' more than makes up for any anxiety I may feel.

    I learned this first lesson. Onwards! I'm ready for the next challenge.

Comments

  1. Fantasy of You
    I hope you, and the many others, find the courage to post your work. There is so little being submitted at the minute, perhaps because of this reason!

    Good luck!

    - Andy
  2. Rinney
    Imo,
    You took the words right out of my mouth. You somehow managed to explain, using the right words, everything that I've been feeling and thinking(and for me personally this pertains to alot of things). I think in the end you have to trust your gut and your heart and say whats on your mind. If every critique said the same things and gave the same advice, then every story or peom or song, would be the same. All you can hope for is that whoever your critiquing takes the ideas and advice you've given them and applys it to whatever it is their writing. As for posting your own material, I'm not going to lie I'm a little nervous. Many doubts enter my mind when I think about putting my thoughts out their for everyone to see. Will anyone think my story's any good and give me some feedback? Will everyone think I'm this stupid teenager that doesn't know how to write or think I can't write simply because I'm younger? Will I bare the very depths of my soul for others to see only for them to tell me that it's not good enough? When it comes down to it I think all you can do is have faith in yourself as a writer and believe that no matter what any bad critique may say, your work is worth something. Not just to you, but eventually others.

    -Rinney
  3. Rinney
    Imo,
    You took the words right out of my mouth. You somehow managed to explain, using the right words, everything that I've been feeling and thinking(and for me personally this pertains to alot of things). I think in the end you have to trust your gut and your heart and say whats on your mind. If every critique said the same things and gave the same advice, then every story or peom or song, would be the same. All you can hope for is that whoever your critiquing takes the ideas and advice you've given them and applys it to whatever it is their writing. As for posting your own material, I'm not going to lie I'm a little nervous. Many doubts enter my mind when I think about putting my thoughts out their for everyone to see. Will anyone think my story's any good and give me some feedback? Will everyone think I'm this stupid teenager that doesn't know how to write or think I can't write simply because I'm younger? Will I bare the very depths of my soul for others to see only for them to tell me that it's not good enough? When it comes down to it I think all you can do is have faith in yourself as a writer and believe that no matter what any bad critique may say, your work is worth something. Not just to you, but eventually others.

    -Rinney
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice