Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. TraumatisedEnglishStudent

    TraumatisedEnglishStudent New Member

    Jun 23, 2022
    Likes Received:

    Creative Writing Feedback.

    Discussion in 'Revision and Editing' started by TraumatisedEnglishStudent, Jun 23, 2022.

    Hi!! Could anyone provide feedback for my short story? I am new to writing so this is one of my first creatives. What is in bold, underlined and italics is the stimulus required to use in the first sentence. THANKS!! Its out of 10 and I am in year 12, is this any good?

    “I cannot be awake, for nothing looks to me as it did before.
    Natasha, you mean the world to me, I need you back, I wish you were here to spend your time with me, not anyone else’s - Happy Valentines, Nathan.

    George’s hand tensed as he placed the non-descript piece of paper back onto the bistro table, a paper that had fell out Natasha’s purse as she made her way to the restroom, however he found himself reading it once more, verifying of the last time if it was his doing, but the scribble wasn’t his. he tittered - it was not common for letters to be sent these days, technology rampantly took over the world, a simple text would have sufficed, it would be more secretive too.

    He looked out the grimy Palladian window of the corner café, at the laughing couples who strolled hand-in-hand along the greenish canals, it was a quiet afternoon in the suburban streets of Venice. The air smelt of brewing coffee, but also, imperceptibly of algae.

    George had been looking forward to this Valentine’s weekend, COVID had made it hard to predict whether this trip would go ahead but he had persisted, took a gamble if you will, and secretly planned a surprise getaway anyway. He would not describe himself as a romantic - indeed it was a miracle he had even settled into a relationship. But with Natasha, it was easy. She seemed to inspire a level of commitment that he did not even know he had.

    George thought back to a time in his life where fidelity was not such an issue. Those were the days when he could freely frequent bars and chat up pretty faces as much as he wished. It was freeing for sure, but after the first set of lockdowns hit, that life disappeared entirely. It surprised him how easily he and Natasha had seemed to connect. They had met on one of those ubiquitous dating apps. The ones which seemed to have filled his Facebook newsfeed as the lockdowns dragged on. At the time, those ads only served to remind George of his isolation. But as his boredom increased, he made a profile of his own. It took a few days before he received his first match, and then another day before his next match arrived - a relatively short time frame as his friend would later inform him. Usually it took guys many weeks to get the first match. That fire had been waiting for months. At first George thought that timeframe was odd. His friend was not exceptionally good looking but was passible.And with the amount of people that were on these dating apps, surely it was inevitable that he would have met someone sooner. But as George later discovered, these matches went as quickly as they came. It was difficult, he found, to sustain a digital conversation several times a day with the same person, he felt as if he was jaded, from the already isolated state he was in, longing for interaction and companionship. Although, with Natasha it was different, she wasn’t the most outgoing at first, it took a couple of weeks before she bloomed into the person he knew now, they chatted - maybe for a month or two, but eventually knew each other quite well, as so he thought.

    Whilst George was somewhat disappointed in reading the letter, an immediate sense of realisation came about him. The past of him letting things go was conversed, for he was the one that was let go of, at this moment he wasn’t for say a changed man, but something shifted in him, a sense of regret grew about him.

    The brewer pinged, notifying him the coffee was ready, a small but strong bitter espresso scent stimulated him.

    “George! Where do you want to head out first? Gondola riding?, visiting the palace? Basilica Di San Marco? Whatever fills your cup” Natasha’s voice delighted him from behind as she returned, though provided him with a sense of urgency. His hairs stood up as he scrunched the letter discretely which waited on the table longing for the attention of its mistress, and pushed it into his pockets feeling singular strands of linen tear from his trousers. But Natasha overlooked his actions, instead making a fuss of the smell emitting from the canals that ran on the side of the café - the permeation of ageing algae clotted the nostrils producing a foul odour. But George didn’t pay attention to that, the contents of the letter still dwindled in his mind…

    “Ciao”, They held hands as they walked through the venetian door, though the sky was filled with red amongst the Valentines scenery, George felt a mixture of love and bitterness perspire through the air though it could be the mould peeling off the canals. slowly the two blended into the crowd of couples and tourists, for George would get her back this weekend.
  2. Hammer

    Hammer Moderator Staff Supporter Contributor

    Oct 28, 2018
    Likes Received:
    Hi @TraumatisedEnglishStudent members here post their work for critique from other members to help improve their skills and hone their craft, or to "sandbox" ideas and techniques, and the place to do that is in the workshop.

    There are rules about posting in the workshop - principally we like to see members pay it forward and offer critique of other members' work before posting their own - the reason for this is twofold, firstly to stop new members just grabbing a bit of free feedback and then vanishing into the ether (we are an active and friendly community (well, usually friendly...) and like to see our members get involved) , but mainly because you will learn a lot more about your own work by critiquing the work of others than putting your own up for crit!

    What we don't do is help students with assignments, so I am closing this thread, but FWIW I think your work shows promise, especially if English is not your first language, so don't be disheartened by me closing the thread, instead get involved with the community - it really is the best way to learn
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice