I'm taking a break from one of my books, and started to work on this other one. However, I got so torn between these two characters that I can't decide which one should be the MC. The plot remains pretty much the same regardless of the character. The base line of plot: Younger sister of guy in boy garage band becomes member of the band and hilarity and a rom-com ensues. So, tell me the girl you think would give my story the best plotline and why! Nikki Nikki is the younger sister of the lead guitarist and founder of the band, and the two of them have a typical "squabbling-siblings" relationship. She's a bit shy and doesn't really like big crowds or things like that. Hobby-wise (outside of the band), Nikki does art and hangs out with her friends, usually her best friend, Diana. She is a bit of a tomboy and doesn't really care about fashion. Nikki has a bit of a sarcastic streak, and often comments on the crazy antics of the band, but deep down, she really does care about them. Pros: I think she's a character a lot of girls could relate to. Cons: I don't feel a strong attachment to her and so I don't think I could write her well. Diana Diana is the younger sister of the bassist, but, in contrast to Nikki, she's very close to her brother. She's Nikki's best friend, but they're opposites: Diana is outgoing, flirty, and loves fashion; but she usually refurbishes cheap clothes instead of buying high-end. She works as a part-time waitress and is a member of the basketball team. She does agree with Nikki that the guys are usually crazy, and usually just sits back and watches the chaos unfold, but she does try to help them when she can. Pros: I feel that I could write her well and I am attached to her. Cons: I fear she won't capture my audience. Thoughts?