My Grading Scale A+ = Get this published. Now! A = This is really good. I want to read it again. A- = This is almost really good, with a few minor fumbles. B+ = This is good with some really enjoyable qualities. B = I can honestly say I enjoyed this. B- = This is slightly ahead of the curb. C+ = This is average, with a few qualities I liked. C = This is average. C- = This is okay. A little below average. D+ = If you work really hard, this can become good. D = If you work really hard, this can become decent. D- = I wouldn't bother revising this. F = Don't even bother revising this. How I Review One of the minor gripes I have with this community is the narrow scope it applies when reviewing posts. I see reviewers annotate posts with detailed precision, and focus too narrowly on the mechanics of each sentence. I believe a reviewer should evaluate a piece more as a whole. Especially if the poster clearly has a grasp on grammar, there is no need to fixate too heavily on each sentence. More often than not, the poster can revise the mechanics of a piece on his or her own. What the poster may not understand is how his or her piece in its entirety affects an unbiased reader. With this in mind, I strongly encourage reviewers on this site to widen the scopes of their reviews.