I Said Something

By GrahamLewis · Mar 28, 2019 · ·
  1. As I've mentioned before, I have a cognitively-disabled son, on the autistic spectrum, which I think makes me sensitive to the way these folks are sometimes treated in the "real world." There's something especially vulnerable in a human being who can't play the social game well. We've been fortunate that most of our outside helpers (e.g. non-family and paid), from therapists to teachers to home-care aids, have been reliable and compassionate. But I worry about when we are gone and he has to rely on his twin sister and the "kindness of strangers."

    It says something about our society that we pay our athletes and entertainers, and business moguls, so much money, but are so parsimonious with money for real human needs. I know that agencies usually struggle to find quality help, because the salaries offered are so low and the needs can be so great (and the clients can be so difficult). So I temper my criticism of paid helpers (not those dealing with my son) as much as I can, because I know that it's hard for me to judge from the outside -- and that if I don't have the ability to make things better I will probably just make it worse.

    And not only paid helpers. I am sometimes haunted by a scene I recall from the waiting room for my son's speech therapist. A kid came in, was wheeled in really by a young couple. He obviously had little muscle control and relied on a wheelchair. He seemed a typical kid of about 6, big glasses and nicely-dressed. He had a pack of cards, I think baseball cards, in his lap and he somehow spilled them. The male part of the couple got really mad at the kid and scolded him, and made him struggle to pick the cards up. I wanted to say something, but held back -- I suspected the man was the mother's boyfriend, and she seemed sort of mousy or cowed. I knew that the best I could do was temporarily have some effect, but more likely embarrass and anger the boyfriend, who would likely take it out on the couple later.

    That's what I thought, and told myself, and it was probably true. But it bothered me then, and bothers me now.

    I thought of this because when I am at the gym usually one or more adult clients, cognitively-challenged, are brought in with a staff member of a local agency. The guys (usually they are guys) are guided to the treadmills and allowed to exercise. Some staff members stay with their client and coax and coach -- but others take the opportunity to sit and chat on their cell phone, paying little or no attention to the client. It irks me and I know it's a common problem -- my sister is a manager at a mental retardation agency in another city, and said it's one of her biggest issues with staff. But they have to handle it carefully, because staff members are so hard to find.

    Anyway, until today I've gone through my exercise routine and bitten my tongue, knowing that as long as the clients are safe, it's not really my business. Today, though, the staff member was sitting on a bench while his client was on a treadmill, totally out of sight. After while I noticed that the client's treadmill had stopped (the time was up) and he was simply standing there, trying to figure out what to do. I walked over to the staff member and said, simply, "your client's treadmill has stopped." He gave me a dirty look, got up, and walked over to the client, phone in hand, did some scant interaction, started the treadmill again, sat on another piece of equipment far from me, and resumed his conversation on the phone.

    And that was that. I did what I could, and maybe helped a little, but it was doubtful. Though I did feel a bit, if not better, at least less frustrated. If that makes sense.
    Matt E, Sam 69, O.M. Hillside and 2 others like this.

Comments

  1. paperbackwriter
    I did a stint of coaching a disabled guy at a gym. He wouldn't let me sit down and play with my phone. he was my "boss" and he could easily get me fired.
  2. Magus
    My mum works with dementia and alzheimers patients. It's pretty bad what goes on behind closed doors in some of these nursing homes. I also have an aunt back in Italy who is mentally handicapped. My mum and my aunt here in Canada make sure to check in on her as often as possible as she's in a care facility. It's when the families stop showing up that they know they can get away with abuse.
  3. paperbackwriter
    in defence of workers/nurses at nursing homes i will say they are often given ridiculous workloads. like a ratio of 1 to 50. spend too much time with one patient puts you behind schedule. I did 3 months in an aged care facility 5 years ago.
  4. GrahamLewis
    Paper, even though you seem to like to beat yourself up, I'm sure if you were in this situation you would do just fine. I'm no saint and your no devil. I too have been -- still can be -- the complainer from hell. In almost any retail situation, especially if I'm convinced either that I'm in the right or that the other has been really in the wrong. That doesn't count the various battles with son's school or providers.
  5. Sam 69
    I completely understand the whole dilemma around knowing whether or not to intervene in situations and whether it is a positive or a negative experience for the intervener.

    My example is of a rather more trivial nature. I am constantly observing visitors to our city struggling with it's chaotic and confusing public transportation system. I often feel the need to help when I see some foreign visitor attempting to make their needs understood to a bus driver or to a ticket seller on the local train.

    I don't do this automatically any longer. It has become clear to me that not everybody wants my assistance - perhaps they want the sense of achievement that comes from doing something for yourself, or perhaps they think I have some ulterior motive in offering help - why has this guy come forward when everybody else on the bus is ignoring the situation? It's also become apparent to me that the information that I impart is often just as confusing to them as that which they have received from the public transport official. Short of personally escorting them to their destination there is not much more that I can do.

    My rather simple conclusion is that acting in such situations does not always bring the anticipated level of personal satisfaction.
  6. GrahamLewis
    My wife and I were in Bratislava Slovakia last year, trying to find our way to our hotel from where the bus dropped us off. We weren't able to find the right city bus stop because of construction, and a woman came up to us, figured out where we were going. Rather than try to explain, she went several blocks out of her way to lead us there.

    And years earlier, when we moved to our current city, we were trying to drive with our little kids to a restaurant and couldn't work out the streets. A guy tried to explain it, then said to just follow him and he led us there.

    Sometimes people are just nice.
      CerebralEcstasy likes this.
  7. Matt E
    This can be a fine line. Some small advice from my experience (more on physical disabilities than mental; I know more of the former than the latter): people with disabilities want to live normal lives and to receive the same respect as anyone else. Yes, help them when they need it, but also understand that they often do not want help doing things that they can do by themselves.

    People are people and there are a lot of different ways to go through life. Best of luck with your son. I do not know the circumstances of course but many people on the spectrum have been able to achieve fully functional, successful lives. Shoot for the moon if you can.
  8. GrahamLewis
    Back to my time working with my quadraplegic friends. First, they would hate to be identified by their condition and we never did so around them or mutual friends. I remember how irritated one guy got when he was being pushed onto an elevator by one of his helpers -- some well-meaning guy said, "make room for the wheelchair." As though the person in it were irrelevant. Second , we soon treated them exactly as roommates, not pity people; we got mad at each other, and had fun together, as friend and equal. Third, they were very careful to do what they could -- which wasn't a lot -- and to accept help when they needed it.

    As for my son, he will likely never be independent, though we're still working toward that. When I think about the spectrum, I think about autistic kids I know of who have very disruptive stims, or are self-destructive or violent. We have none of that. My son is gentle and mostly happy, and fully acknowledges us (parents) and his neurotypical twin sister. For which I am grateful.
      CerebralEcstasy likes this.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice