Strange.

By tehuti88 · Aug 23, 2008 · ·
  1. A little while back I rated a thread here two stars, not because I disagreed with it, but because what I had thought would be some sort of discussion of a news article turned instead into a bunch of people ranting and raving and basically patting each other on the back as they all agreed on a particular subject. I can't go into more detail without giving away the thread itself, but I had kind of hoped that there would be some actual civilized discussion/debate of the topic at hand, which is a very heated topic. But it was just a big lynch mob, and very saddening to read. I didn't comment because I knew anything I said could be misconstrued (thus proving my point), and just rated it a two. I purposefully avoided a followup post by the same person because I felt it would be exactly the same and I didn't want to appear like I was "stalking" to give bad ratings (something that happened to me on a different site in the past).

    Today I see what appears to be the very same thread I rated and there is still just one rating on it, BUT, it is five stars. Meaning that either my rating was deleted and someone else's was added, or else mine was changed. I lean toward the former, truthfully. But either way it seems terribly unethical. Why should my rating count less because I disagreed? Doesn't that rather nullify the whole point of rating?

    If there's some sort of site rule against voting on threads without commenting then I guess I understand. But I wasn't aware of this, and either way, like I said, whatever happened to my rating seems terribly unfair. I didn't speak up to explain my rating as I didn't really feel inclined to invite the wrath of the lynch mob. Been there before, done that. Not worth the trouble. I thought one rating and then letting it go would suffice, but now that my rating is apparently gone (I can't be 100% sure, but it seems that way to me), it seems I'm not allowed that opinion.

    This makes me rather leery of remaining on an otherwise decent site. :(

    Not that I think anyone will notice this post, but I won't be replying to any comments on it. I'm tired of dealing with other people's drama; I have my opinions and I stick by them. Just like the people in that thread. The only difference is, apparently they're allowed their opinion and I'm not.

Comments

  1. Shadow Dragon
    I think everyone should be allowed their opinion. That sucks that your rating seemed to disappear.
  2. Banzai
    I wasn't aware ratings could be deleted or changed...

    To be honest, we don't use the star ratings all that much on this site. They're just a vbulletin feature that's there, more than anything. But if something odd like this does crop up, you're much better PMing a mod about it. We won't bite or anything. I'll take a look into it for you, could you please PM me the thread details?
  3. Raven
    When someone rates a thread *Cough* Gary Glitter* Cough* it carries that rating. When someone else rates the same thread if they rate it say five stars it becomes a three star rating taking into account the lower rating. If someone else rates it say 4 stars it remains at three stars. if two more people rate it 5 stars it becomes a four star and then another 5 star rating will make it a 5 star rating. And that is the reason that *cough* Gary Glitter *Cough* thread became a 5 star rating. Personally I'm completely baffled as to why your so bothered. If you felt it a lynch mob you should say so. And not rate it a low rate without passing comment.

    Everyone has an opinion and if you felt strongly about the lynch mobbing then maybe explaining why would have helped.

    However you really are not the only person to rate threads I believe there is a full forums worth of members who also have views and feel of rating threads.

    Ratings cannot be deleted once they have been given. Personally rating threads in the lounge is pointless in my humble opinion because the lounge is for general chat.
  4. Still Life
    Well, it did feel like a lynch mob there, so any number of explaining from a different standpoint would have received the reactions that cough lemex cough got >_>;;;, but I'm not even sure we're talking about the same thread so I'll just zip it.
  5. Raven
    I used Gary Glitter as an example. The point is the ratings cannot be deleted and do change as they recieve different ratings from other members.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice