Interesting Thought Experiment

  1. I heard a quote once, "you die twice- first when your body dies and second the last time someone remembers you."

    Which made me think, if you die the last time someone remembers you, do you live the first time when someone thinks of you the first time?

    Imagining if it were true, then you were born the first time your mom thought of you when she was pregnant with you. But what is thinking of you?

    You could have been born when your grandmother thought of a grandchild in the future. Or when your great ancestors from the 1800s thought of their distant future offspring.

    Why do people directly related to you have to birth you for the first time? Anyone in the past who was capable of thought in the past would have.

    If thinking of you is thinking of anything you could be and any category you could fit in, you would have been born many times.

    When did humans become able to think into the distant future? Science says the more fully developed cortex developed 5 million years ago.

    So, whenever an early neanderthal thought about the people of the future, you were born for the first time.
    Which also means whenever you think of the next generations, billions of people are born for the first time.

    Food for thought.

    -Adrian
    Cave Troll and Malisky like this.

Comments

  1. Chekhov's pen
    When you're remembered, they actually know (at least a little bit about) you.
    Before you're born, it's hard to imagine someone thinking about -YOU-, specifically. Also they could be wrong. For example, we could be exterminated by an advanced alien species tomorrow (they want to move our moon to their homeworld for obvious reasons), do all those billions of future humans die? I don't know man, that means thinking about progeny might turn out to be genocide. Also you might think you're going to have children in the future, and then you turn out to be sterile/infertile.
    Also, what if everyone you've ever met dies in a nuclear tsunami, and nobody thinks about you anymore? Do you have your second death before your first, and can you be reborn by making a new friend? Then you can die more than twice.
    Also how does this relate to bacteria and cancer cells (both of which are effectively immortal, and they divide so you don't know which individual it is you were thinking about) or, if you want to go for animals, Turritopsis dohrnii?
    Technical issues! :dead:
    I'm sorry, I was trained as an engineer.
  2. Lifeline
    Could be the premise for a original story though :D
      Malisky and Authentically Adrian like this.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice