I agree entirely. However, I also think their are some critters (not the fuzzy kind) who tend to completely rewrite something. I've done it, though I try to explain why and tell them "of course, rewrite in your own words". I don't think it's intended as disrespectful (ever) but I personally find it annoying. It doesn't mean I don't want them to bother though. I still appreciate the effort and take from it what I can. I think that's probably what it comes down to - it's our responsibility to take what we can use and discard the rest. Anyone who crits - it's their opinion and they're never infallible. None of us are. Would it be great if everyone explained why? Of course it would, but they're not going to.