Speedwell Cavern in Derbyshire. This is an underground cavern accessed by boat. They take you there and leave you on an outcrop of ground while they take the previous tourists back. It's quite scary, water too cold and deep to wade, low roof, depending on how much rain there's been. I did worry as the boat sailed away leaving us there... what if it did 't come back for us. If it rained heavy would the water reach the tunnel roof leaving the caver cut off. I will never go down there again.
Trapped near the bottom of a giant underwater facility, slowly filling up with water, top down, and being crushed under it's own weight and pressure. For reference play Ever 17 a classic VN.
Or how about in a case of mistaken identity they get stranded in a Civil War re-inactment. Oh my god. Which of the thousands of performers is the killer?